this post was submitted on 20 May 2026
6 points (100.0% liked)
Technology
1443 readers
32 users here now
A tech news sub for communists
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Trying to be fair to it and assess based on what I can find there:
Pros:
The section about "possible futures" seems to be centering indigenous / sovereign AI projects, among others, which suggests the point is not to be knee-jerk anti-AI tech, but rather center a more liberation perspective on it, so good.
Mixed:
Some of the suggestions, like joining a labor coalition, are not bad advice, but like... centering it around AI seems to be a bit tunnel-vision.
Cons:
Choose Democracy is apparently a Yankee thing about fighting for "democracy". So... maintaining the liberal democracy power structure?
This seems to be referencing the term one of their people, the author of Empires of AI, coined. I have not read the book, but a quick look for info on wikipedia alleges:
So anti-imperialist and anti-colonial from the sound of it, but why reduce it to "empires of AI"? AI in the hands of the western empire is an arm of it, not the empire itself. I hope they are not trying to say China is one of these "empires", but I don't want to accuse without evidence, so I will leave it at that.
This may be more of a personal thing, but I find the term slop to refer to AI to be very unhelpful and reductionist as criticism. The followup described here might be a good thing, but the example of "microslop" as a viral term like it's a good thing seems very internet-brain to me. People should be thinking about narrative on a deeper level than trying to dunk on big corp AI in a reactive way. The big corp AI isn't magically worse because it's big corp and in fact it is among some of the most capable AI out there. The problem with it is other things, like who has power over it.
Far from an exhaustive assessment, but I wanted to write something because on the surface, it seems to be very Yankee concept of social change (which can often be shallow and liberal).
it's a mostly-American resource for mostly-Americans. I don't think it tries to be more than that. Also most of the power pushing AI is in the USA. Resisting it from the provinces of the empire with a localist strategy won't do much.