rugarc

joined 2 months ago
[–] rugarc@lemmygrad.ml 4 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago) (3 children)

ah hmmm, maybe I should've asked the context of the question directly 😅 (I'll also edit the main post with context). I was confused how the american working class relates to the means of production. so my setup is that in the context of imperialism, the production of people's needs mainly happens outside of america, and it seems that americans' primary source of wealth and well-being comes from those superprofits

so then americans as a whole seem to have power in maintaining this system, from protecting it via participating in the military, working in jobs that manage this imperial system (e.g. finance, defense, etc.), selecting the american candidates that pursue their favorite imperialist policies (i.e the policies that give them a larger share of the super profits). in turn, the domestic capitalists in america need the support of the americans, so they and the americans come to an agreement on how to divide the superprofits from the factories abroad among them

so, in the broader sense of imperialism, it seems to me that american capitalists and the group of average americans share ownership in the means of production, in a primary sense. but is there something wrong in this reasoning?

 

hi! I was discussing with a few different people about how the american working class relates to the means of production in the context of imperialism

so my setup is that in the context of imperialism, production of people’s needs mainly happens outside of america, and it seems that americans’ primary source of wealth and well-being comes from those superprofits

so then americans as a whole seem to have power in maintaining this system, from protecting it via participating in the military, working in jobs that manage this imperial system (e.g. finance, defense, etc.), selecting the american candidates that pursue their favorite imperialist policies (i.e the policies that give them a larger share of the super profits). in turn, the domestic capitalists in america need the support of the americans, so they and the americans come to an agreement on how to divide the superprofits from the factories abroad among them

so, in the broader sense of imperialism, it seems to me that american capitalists and the group of average americans share ownership in the means of production. what are everyone's thoughts?

(I edited the post to make the context clearer, originally I had asked an abstract question about ownership that didn't get at the imperialism context)

[–] rugarc@lemmygrad.ml 4 points 2 months ago

I'm glad there's a lot communist content on YouTube which I feel can get marxist thought a lot of visibility, but for me the YouTube UI feels like it's sometimes constantly bombarding me to click on things or scroll to the comments and it's a bit distracting sometimes... I definitely prefer the far more focused experience of reading theory instead

but there are also a lot of realllly good first-hand video sources on YouTube, not necessarily breadtube, that can be super fun to watch. one that comes to mind is "An African-American's Journal Inside North Korea (1994)", even though not all of the thoughts voiced in it are explicitly marxist. that one made a pretty big impression on me when I watched it for the first time :D

[–] rugarc@lemmygrad.ml 7 points 2 months ago (1 children)

this is really inspiring actually! I've been thinking about coming out irl to more people than just some very close friends, it's nice to hear someone else's experience since it's so nervewracking to think about while other aspects of my life are so busy... sometimes I'm like, maybe I shouldn't do this, is there any point, surely I can manage living as a guy towards the public for the rest of my life if I've already done it for so long. but then of course, every instance of gender euphoria keeps changing my opinion... :D

[–] rugarc@lemmygrad.ml 2 points 2 months ago

Hi!! Yes it's been a great experience :D

[–] rugarc@lemmygrad.ml 1 points 2 months ago

Ah I see, yeah moving to a city seems like something you are heavily considering trying out, so I really hope you're able to figure something out in terms of passports and transportation and things. it's a worthwhile pursuit for sure

Oh wait, I didn't realize messages were a thing on lemmygrad! I'll head out for now, but I'll send a message later today when I'm free to talk again :)

[–] rugarc@lemmygrad.ml 1 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago) (2 children)

Yeah it's really unfortunate that exposure therapy requires risking the resulting intense (potentially traumatic) discomfort....

Ahh I see. Yeah going to a city seems like it'd definitely give you more opportunity/flexibility to change your current situation, definitely seems like a reasonable option to consider

[–] rugarc@lemmygrad.ml 1 points 2 months ago (4 children)

Absolutely, I guess the first thing I'd ask is, is there anything specific about it that you'd want to talk about? Also, have you looked into ERP (exposure and response prevention)?

In either case, maybe some of the following is relatable: assuming we have the same theme, I think one smaller compulsion I had was looking away from the TV/computer/phone whenever an advertisement or show or something had the target of the theme. So one thing that my therapist told me to do at the time was to resist the compulsion to turn my head away. Other (more difficult to tackle) compulsions included me moving really far away from said type of person (off my natural walking trajectory). I try to continue to walk in the direction I was walking as much as possible to counter this. I'm not completely out of the woods yet with this theme, but I think tackling many of my compulsions like this and other examples helped a bit.

[–] rugarc@lemmygrad.ml 1 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago) (6 children)

Unfortunately I'm too young (college-age) to feel confident giving you any long-term advice... although actually I read your post earlier about direction in life, in which I saw you mentioned OCD, which I also suffer from, and we might even have the same theme based on your description. so if you feel comfortable talking about that/have anything you want to talk with me regarding that I can say my thoughts on it, don't feel pressured at all to talk about it though (I didn't bring it up earlier since I was worried as to whether you'd want to talk about it or not)

But yeah, I'm also in the process of thinking about my life trajectory so I hesitate to really give advice on that front, since I think my thoughts on life goals might drastically change as the next few years go on (depending on how things go in America as well)

[–] rugarc@lemmygrad.ml 1 points 2 months ago (8 children)

Yeah, the pressures of college are horrible when dealing with mental health issues that make deadlines super stressful (like I feel like college just doesn't give people space to take days off (much less hours off) and really confront their struggles and direction in life, it's just a constant stream of work and other pressures)

The factory work/local work is a cool choice! one of my friends was talking about doing something like that as well and I've definitely had that option in mind as well

[–] rugarc@lemmygrad.ml 1 points 2 months ago (10 children)

Yeah, I also live in America it's really bad... and thinking about all of the complicity of working in any American company is really rough. I'm curious, are there other kinds of companies you'd be fine working at? Personally my plan is to continue with a research/academic route, so that's also an option (although within academics there's a lot of suspicious ties with defense and Israel and stuff so it's rough to even find something fulfilling in academia)

[–] rugarc@lemmygrad.ml 4 points 2 months ago

Yayyy hope you enjoy the read!

[–] rugarc@lemmygrad.ml 4 points 2 months ago (1 children)

Thanks!! I'm finding it super comfy already, I'm really happy that the community is so welcoming, really heartwarming :D

 

Hi, I just joined lemmygrad! I've been lurking here for a while. About me uhhhh... I really like music, anime, and talking to people in general.

Also, the big reason I wanted to make an account today is because I wanted to recommend some books by Suniti Kumar Ghosh that I've been reading and really enjoying recently. I highly recommend "Naxalbari: Before and After" and "The Tragic Partition of Bengal", where you can learn things like how Gandhi was actually fascist and Gandhi's "non-violence" movement was actually a tool used by the British imperialists (and India's comprador bourgeoisie) to quell the rising anti-imperialist forces. (Suspiciously, Gandhi always seemed to be fine with violence whenever it was the imperialists doing it...)

One of my favorite parts about Ghosh is that they use so many quotes by members of the ruling class where the ruling class admits to their plans. It's literally evil villain reveals evil plan so it's basically irrefutable. Like Ghosh includes a quote by A. O. Hume literally explaining that the founding of the Indian National Congress was designed to "inoculate them ["the great lower middle classes"] with a mild and harmless form of political fever"... and there's so many quotes like this in the book from British officials and their puppets that make it blatantly clear how Indian "independence" in 1947 didn't liberate India at all.)

Anyways, my fangirling about Ghosh's works aside, I'm excited to be here and to get to know you all!! :)

view more: next ›