this post was submitted on 29 Mar 2026
40 points (100.0% liked)

Ask Lemmygrad

1289 readers
81 users here now

A place to ask questions of Lemmygrad's best and brightest

founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
 

The US aggression against Iran has generated even more political fervor. This is something I've witnessed in my closest circles with a Mamdani-lib sibling of mine commenting that "North Korea's also never done anything" which was a shock to hear given some of our previous conversations.

My partner has made even more progress. They've almost completely flipped on many stances in regards to countries amongst the "axis of evil".

This has all led me to wonder: What's the best way to take advantage of the turmoil, and push temporary-baby-leftists to a more concrete position?

Thinking of something like the guide's Cowbee puts out but even more digestible for entry level -potential communists, really want to create lasting impressions that generate questions.

top 21 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] TheRedWedge@lemmygrad.ml 18 points 2 days ago (1 children)

With my past experience of trying to get people to read the most basic, short, easy and lib-friendly texts and 10-20 minute articles, I wouldn't go for the approach of dropping a reading list on them unless they are the types who read encyclopedias for fun, or they actually ask you for reading material. And I wouldn't go straight to communist theory with proletariat and classes and scary German philosophers and Russian revolutionaires either.

Theory is essential but you need to ease people into it. Make sure that you are up to date yourself with literature that deals with issues relevant to your friends, and that isn't just straight up Marx or Lenin because libs are primed to be hostile towards those. In the case of US aggression, I would recommend stuff like Washington Bullets, Killing Hope, Against Empire, or The Jakarta Method. Then, since you mentioned these are people close to you that you interact with on a regular basis, spend time with them, listen to them, and capitalize on every opportunity to drop more of your leftist analysis while pointing at the resources that you used to build it. Essentially, you have to market reading to them by being well informed on topics they care about and showing the work that got you here.

I know a few people similar to your friends who are starting to question the official narrative on countries like Iran and the DPRK. One of them asked me for a link to Killing Hope, but this was after he brought up North Korea himself in light of recent events and we spent some time talking about the Korean War, its many associated US crimes against humanity, as well as how this pattern of US aggression repeated throughout the post WW2 world. I have no idea if the guy will actually read it, but if he does it will be easier to build on that and pitch Lenin to him.

We are fighting against a wall of heavily reinforced anticommunist narratives and liberal civil religion, which is why I prefer the cautious approach. Marxist-Leninist reading lists are for people who have broken through and decided they want to make sense of the world after the liberal narrative has collapsed. You need to work with your friends at their own pace and drill at the cracks that form organically until they get to that point.

[–] BarrelsBallot@lemmygrad.ml 7 points 2 days ago (1 children)

Many great answers on this post, including yours. I definitely share the frustration you've experience in trying to get other's to read basics. I think what I want to pursue is "content" with an emphasis on impression generation- since I can almost guarantee this type of media captures the most attention of contemporary audiences (think tiktok, instagram, YT shorts, <10 minute YT videos). None of these mediums are stand-ins for the tried and true, (books) but I'd go as far as to say that they're the best for provoking questions. Especially since most aren't willing to dedicate an hour or so to reading / watching some blowback pod episode.

Perhaps there's some merit in taking a Cowbee-style reading list and matching the themes with short form content (1 min videos, images, tweets) sort of akin to the pamphlets communists of the past would create for the less educated workers.

Regardless, thank you for sharing your thoughts-- πŸ™‚

[–] TheRedWedge@lemmygrad.ml 5 points 2 days ago

I have ADHD and my own shame pile of half finished books so I empathize with how hard it can be to just sit down and read the damn theory. I definitely think you have a good basis with the idea of compiling short and impactful tiktok/insta/youtube content as a jumping board for delving deeper. In fact, the thing that pushed me to make the effort and start reading in my very own political journey was watching youtube videos in my lunch break that had a bibliography in the description and directly cited the works during the clip. These are significantly longer than what you are going for and I know he is guilty of his own fair share of cringe, but I give a lot of credit to Bad Empanada's videos on the historical link between the USian concept of Manifest Destiny and the Nazis' Lebensraum and the one on the invention of the modern concept of the white race on this. I distinctly remember watching him lay it out straight from the books and thinking to myself "damn this is crazy stuff I really need to read more".

In a way, the strategy I pursued above is simply emulating that experience with my friends when the opportunity arises, except that I play the part of the youtube video in real life and hope my analysis is good enough to prompt them to want to learn more for themselves.

Good luck in your endeavors, hopefully we both get some extra comrades out of this. I'm actually quite hopeful myself after hearing my friends independently question the narrative on Iran, it really feels like the world is slowly changing. Right now, as communists, we need to do our best to reach people who are willing to listen and help them get started on the path of liberating political education.

[–] Conselheiro@lemmygrad.ml 14 points 2 days ago

Show them reporting from Liberation News and Fight Back News, for a start. Also the Abby Martin documentaries, and Yellow Parenti. I think there's a whole Parenti Lecture podcast made by an user from here. Those are all good for broader anti-imperialism.

For Marxism specifically, Engels already perfected the introduction with Principles of Communism. Vijay Prashad's videos and interviews are fairly accessible to broad audiences. And if they get too curious, you can feed the Wage Labour and Capital, and Value, Price and Profit but at that point you're better off just making a joint commitment to join some party together.

But most importantly, try to approach other active communists and socialists. If there are protests nearby, try to find out if the left acronyms (FRSO/PSL/CPUSA/DSA/etc/etc) are gonna be there and hang around together with them. It's way easier when it's humans talking to each other.

[–] amemorablename@lemmygrad.ml 10 points 2 days ago (2 children)

I've been meaning to try my hand at some kind of "primer". This is as good a reason as any, so I went and tried to cover some of what I think are the most important concepts. I'm not sure if this is more digestible than already existing material, but based on the material I've encountered in the past, I tried to condense and simplify without losing the heart of the meaning. Ideally, this would at most be an intro to someone doing deeper learning about it. (Also, if there's anything I'm oversimplifying, i.e. losing important meaning in the process of trying to simplify, I'm open to correction.)

Diamat: Short for dialectical materialism. Also applied to history as historical materialism. The prevailing scientific theory of change. Things have internal contradictions. Big changes come from buildup of quantitative to qualitative (ex: water reaching boiling point). Base and superstructure both matter (base: concrete conditions, such as access to house and food, superstructure: belief/tradition layer, such as religion, culture, and media). People both change belief and are changed by it. People both change the concrete and are changed by it. Means of production (such as land, factories) and distribution (such as telecommunications and roads) shape and reshape how a society functions. Over time, the way people are positioned in relation to these can bring about a boiling point and create the conditions for dramatic change from one system to another.

Communist: Communists are part scientist, but they are not passive observers. They are active participants in working toward a particular kind of change. In the abstract, communists believe in a stateless, classless, moneyless society; the elimination of class and caste stratification, and dominating power structures. In practice, liberation effort requires transition (see: diamat and dynamics of change). However, this does not mean trying to reform a repressive system from within.

Means of production and distribution: Who controls these controls the direction of a society. Should a factory build bombs or medicine? Should the airways tout the virtues of capitalism or socialism? Should elected officials be able to enrich themselves or be considered as public servants, dedicated to the people's needs over all else? If an exploiting class, such as the capitalist class, controls these, can you reform it from within? No. You need to have control over it. But who?

Vanguard party: A disciplined, militant, and scientific socialist vanguard of the people has been proven multiple times to be an effective means of acquiring and managing control over the means of production and distribution. The reaction to a change in power, at home and/or abroad, will be violent in various forms. It may come as direct war, or as attempts at assassination, color revolution, economic embargo, sanctions. The vanguard is necessary to ensure the revolution both stays in power and stays on a disciplined scientific socialist path through difficult times of transition from the previous system to a new, more humane one.

Color revolution: A form of "fake" revolution, where an outside force seizes on real discontent and/or tries to manufacture discontent, and then tries to take control of the resulting movements and direct them toward changing the hands of power. This is a common tactic of imperialism, historically, in order to subvert sovereign powers and replace their leadership with someone who is subservient to the empire; someone who will, in essence, sell out their own people to the highest bidder.

Imperialism: Capitalism's parasitic nature develops beyond internal feeding to external feeding. Nations become resources to be targeted for exploitation. Land, labor, and natural resources are turned toward the enrichment of the imperial capitalists, with conscious intent to make these countries more dependent on imports and their imperial masters. Not to be confused with infrastructure investment in another country, inherently (see: China's non-predatory efforts to help other countries with infrastructure).

Actually Existing Socialism (AES / AES state): A term for countries that are led by a communist vanguard party. These countries have not all taken the same path because their conditions were not and are not identical, nor were the cultures and systems of belief that they arose out of. However, they share a commonality of being heavily vilified by the empire, relentlessly targeted with attempts at color revolution, and in spite of this, tend to have astounding track records for advancing the quality of life of their people in relatively short periods of time. Note: This does not mean their people all live in pure luxury. They do well with the conditions they have to work with. Their conditions are often a worse starting point than ruling empire states.

[–] BarrelsBallot@lemmygrad.ml 3 points 2 days ago (1 children)

Would I share this text with someone directly? Probably not.

Do I think this is perfect study material for myself to reinterpret / regurgitate during my own conversations? Absolutely- and I will do so, thanks!

I like that. Whatever use you can get out of it, that's something.

[–] Maeve@lemmygrad.ml 3 points 2 days ago (1 children)

Well done, comrade! Sharing this with two I know who may be receptive!

[–] amemorablename@lemmygrad.ml 4 points 2 days ago (1 children)

Right on, hope it makes a difference. πŸ™

[–] Maeve@lemmygrad.ml 2 points 1 day ago

Well one is largely a done deal. The other may be if their family would stop spewing maga crap, but they're receptive.

[–] cenarius@lemmygrad.ml 5 points 2 days ago* (last edited 2 days ago) (1 children)

Americans do not have brains πŸ§ β›” for you that is. They will listen to Sam Altman. I recently explained over the phone after being informed of how smart he was in a documentary that he

CW: sexual assault of practically a BABY

raped his like 3 year old sister with his siblings when he was 12 years old

& for years his family has persisted in tormenting her in poverty despite their lavish wealth etc, I won't belabor it we know all these people are psychopaths. But I want to highlight this is the exact kind of abuse story these people do engage with over stories from the global south. Yet the response was literally "how old were they" [explanation] [shocked silence] "I don't know why you have to be so negative ... this doc was made by a guy with a shed in his backyardβ€œ (I didn't bother to explain what having a backyard means in the states) etc etc, these people are just disconnected from reality, suffering does not urge them, their self-interest does not correlate to their lifespan because they are unrealistic about getting into the asset market. I hope the current crisis gets much worse. I want them to listen to chill Indian guys not Elon Musk's dad if presented right with high production value.

Anyways I know that's a dumb anecdotal example & we're supposed to brainstorm how to reach those people. Maybe it's my disconnection. I only care about the Vietnamese petrochemical industry now. I could be misjudging how close people are there to freaking out like I did. But IMO make extreme life changes in a concerted effort to be safe & happy. Do not buy into the asset market. Before I left the US I didn't realize the apartment I last lived in never informed me it was in a flood zone, because legally they got rid of the requirement... insanr. You CAN be Hurricane Katrina'd before the economy Officially Collapses. Free yourself & do something good while there is still time

[–] Orcinus@lemmygrad.ml 8 points 2 days ago (1 children)

I fault COCSA on poor sex ed and parenting more than on the individual.

[–] cenarius@lemmygrad.ml 4 points 2 days ago* (last edited 2 days ago) (1 children)

The whole story about the will & gaslighting her over it is out there if you search for it. It's psychopath/bloodless freak environment behavior. When it's kids left alone by an overworked single parent that fits your description but in these cloistered private communitiesof the superrich they are being raised on generations upon generations of impunity, the idea money should be used to control others & that's good (servants etc), limited empathy, & they have the most resources to educate their kids & prevent this stuff. It's not saying "oh this company is bad bc it has a bad culture that put this guy in charge" e.g. Blizzard is bad bc of the milking thing (nvm don't ask), Blizzard is bad bc it got more egambling legalized etc. & damages the industry by financializing games & sequels as services instead of being productive. OpenAI core kkkadre is basically an extension of the KKK & CENTCOM (redundant). Only people from Hitler bloodlines get in.

Anyways I actually just had another phone call abt this since they woke up & I explained Eliezer YudrowsKKKy & the Facebookkk "whiSStleblower" legal SCAMS used to push public-private parterSShips so it's chill (βŒβ– _β– ) I'm extremely calm

Also you're kinda on the money they saw a lot of evil shit working at public schools my point is not just that normally they subscribe that purity testing (they do) it's that everyone in the US is ruled by intelligence network pedophiles with SSocial kkkapital to protect them from SSerial KKKiller-level allegations that runs as deep as their families. Then again that isn't unknown to most football teams. I can't be called a conspiracy theorist to say that accompanies protecting generational wealth stolen from slaves, across SEA, from Mexicans, Haitians, everyone really, debt magicKKK. Maybe Maoist Standard English should be used sparingly it takes too long

[–] Orcinus@lemmygrad.ml 8 points 2 days ago (1 children)

Freak environment behavior is the norm. Poor sex ed isn't a result of lack of resources, it's a deliberate means of preventing kids from identifying abuses of power over them or what's right and wrong. Even with the points you make, it reinforces my own that the child is a product of their environment.

The fact that we're using "psychopath" to describe this behavior is proof we're largely undereducated about this. You do not require a mental illness to be a horrendous, selfish asshole. The production and reproduction of power, control, and CSA is unfortunately quite normal in the US and is manifested in different ways even among the poor. I should know.

[–] cenarius@lemmygrad.ml 3 points 2 days ago* (last edited 2 days ago) (2 children)

I just wasn't sure if you knew the extent of the family's abuse from my description & it's the structures these people create that deprive these parents of their time with their kids & community, that spread media that promotes abuse & impunity for abusers.

Yes I think it is bad that people being called gurus of thought in #badfilm doKKKumentaries are visibly psyKKKopaths it is not normal to do that to your baby sister, it is Normal To Have A Bad Brain In AmeriKKKa. The original point about my dumb aneKKKdote in no way hinges on CSA being an exceptional psychological or moral characteristic (okay no more Maoist typing it's inappropriate anyways I'm tired) of the ruling class, but there is a financial, cybernetic, legal, & military infrastructure he is deeply embedded in that relies on it & an ancient aristocratic western practice of it. Nobody is downplaying the frequency & severity of CSA in AmeriKKKa (I lied) just using it as evidence pedophile infraSStructure. The way the media rallied around him would be a good point if it comes up again. He gets his face plastered out there as a role model in spite of his family's treatment of his sister. Another good point would be the intersection between transhumaniSSm & pedophilia in the dataSSenter induSStry.

I am not saying rich people are a separate SSpecies uniquely capable of wrongdoing & that ingenuity produces the structures AmeriKKKans live under. White supremacist ideology does not produce imperialism & you can't just awareness-raise it away. Same with spreading awareness for cancer & substituting messaging for educational resources. Slandering public figureSSS won't help survivors without that either. In most treatment of it, even the rare bits credulous to their stories just use it as a SSpectacle for making money & advocate for legislative pressure. Epstein survivors turn to NGOs & become internet journalists because there is nothing else to work with.

Also, I never said I handled the conversation great the first time & seeing your message right before I got called again helped. Anywayd bit late brb Lemmygrad apologies for the spam veering into bizarre ranting again it will happen again

[–] BarrelsBallot@lemmygrad.ml 6 points 2 days ago (1 children)

Please get a blood panel done and share the results, I wanna know what peptides to get on so I can post the way you do

[–] cenarius@lemmygrad.ml 2 points 1 day ago

*advokkkate

Tianeptine made me normal

[–] Orcinus@lemmygrad.ml 5 points 2 days ago (1 children)

I knew. It's a research point of mine. I was a victim of such abuse myself and my own familial rapist is popular and beloved.

I also know he's nothing out of the ordinary. Most CSA is committed by family members and acquaintance, done for the sake of power and stimulation. My own parents also abused me.

[–] cenarius@lemmygrad.ml 2 points 1 day ago (1 children)

Yeah I wanted to reassure that I'm not saying it's uncommon at all & they should be run over by so many cars + remains obliterated by MIRVs if it came off like doubling down, it's just coffee past 5pm and explaining yourself disease

[–] Orcinus@lemmygrad.ml 3 points 1 day ago (1 children)

I sympathize. But that's also uncomfortable nuance. I'm told that encouraging the death penalty discourages reports because people often don't want their family or acquaintances killed.

[–] cenarius@lemmygrad.ml 2 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago)

This is what I mean about people having to rely on the social capital of their abusers though. The condemnation usually changes nothing. Might enable couch surfing. There is no real community, just clusters of private societies. It makes me miserable to think about it.