Honestly the original post arguing against them makes very valid points that I wasn't expecting to read to the end, even if they probably lost 90%+ of readers with the length that could have been cut down.

Speaking as a GrapheneOS and Linux user, the possibility of remote attestation to stop me from doing so is a legitimately shitty thought.

Been quite a fan of the convenience though as I just hate having to keep my phone on me all the time. So I'm torn, but will continue using them at least until a whiff of big tech buffoonery comes around.

Edit: Ricky's arguments seem sound but I think you can also tack on "for now" to all of them. They also work for Apple so worth mentioning that potential conflict of interest/bias. I'd be curious of GrapheneOS's take.