I'm skeptical that access to information plays that big of a role in practice. What we see is that people just form online bubbles along with other people who have similar beliefs. Take the whole flat earth movement as an example, clearly the abundance of information to the contrary isn't preventing people from believing nonsense. And that's one of the more extremely absurd beliefs, it's much easier for people to believe things like immigrants stealing jobs, or that entrepreneurs are needed for innovation, and so on. Meanwhile, MAGA is basically a cult around Trump, his support hasn't really fallen amongst them even despite the economic damage his trade war is doing.
It'd be interesting to see more perspectives on this from people who know history better, but I see a lot of the same mechanics playing out today as at the start of the 20th century.