this post was submitted on 11 May 2025
154 points (97.0% liked)
science
18485 readers
270 users here now
A community to post scientific articles, news, and civil discussion.
rule #1: be kind
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Can you calculate the weight of a sphere of 9 m of displaced water ?
No ? Well, it is 382 tons.
So, the concrete sphere is already massive by itself. "You" don't need any complicated anchoring.
Same goes with the rest of your mechanical engineering intuitions : you did not work in this domain or study it, did you ๐ ?
Also, stress cycling is bad on most material, yes. But here it is compressive stress and the geometry is symmetric. Without further study, i want to believe this thing has good potential and my intuitions tells me it looks nice. Time will tell ๐ !
Metric strikes again.
I bet you didn't even have to convert through football fields, elephants, or olympic sized swimming pools!
indeed i made a very simplified calculation not taking into account increase density of salted water nor increased density because of compressibility of water at 500 m deep. Basically i took 1mยณ(water) is 1 (metric) ton.
Thanks for the insight, Iโm not a mechanical engineer, Iโm a software engineer :) The walls on these spheres have got to be pretty thick- 400 tonnes is no joke. 3/4 of a meter if I had to guess.
Perfect guess ! (afaik) ฯ(concrete) โ 2.5 tons/mยณ
so full sphere โ (2.5 x 382) tons = 955 tons
they have 400 t so the cavity removes :
955 - 400 = 555 t ... so 7.51m diam. cavity
... so, yes 3/4m thick wall ๐๐ !
That's exactly the way I would have calculated it, glad someone beat me to it though. Thanks!