I hit up thrift stores to buy movies on disk. I think it's more than 1200 now.
They get ripped and added to my media server, then I store the disks just in case I need them.
While I don't condemn anyone for pirating media, my personal ethics don't allow me to. So, I need to have the purchased, physical copy to keep it on my server.
Last weekend I unpacked them all with a plan to put them in alphabetical order:

Buying used I occasionally get one that's unplayable. When that happens, I borrow a copy from the library to rip.