Don't let it gather dust, let it be your daily ritual. Some things can just be special, you don't have to squeeze the value out of it. A better parallel example for me is that I recently built a computer. Used parts mostly, but top of the line. It can render video about ten times as fast as you can watch it. However, I mostly use it to play indie games and old stuff. It's just a special thing for me, I'm not going to get 4K monitors and start playing AAA games at max settings just because I can.
The same can be true for your coffee. Let it be your special thing, and to hell with the pressure to make the most of it. It's for you, you deserve something nice.