Written by: Russell T Davies

Directed by: Graeme Harper

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [S] 4 points 2 days ago (1 child)

All of the things I said last week still apply, really, and I won't dwell on them too much. RTD finales are messy (though this one isn't as messy as some), the production values are not great (the dimension-hopping devices look particularly cheap and plastic-y). Moving on!

The bickering between the Daleks and the Cybermen is delightful. Turning them into clowns is a pretty fun way to add some depth to two extremely one-dimensional villains.

Another way to do that? Making some of them "special," with personalities of their own. I quite like the Cult of Skaro, even though they lead to that dodgy episode of Spider-Noir in the next season.

The "reunion" between Pete and Jackie is quite good - good enough that I was able to (almost) forget that they stopped dead in a corridor in the middle of a crisis to have it. The push-and-pull of knowing that the other person both is and is not the person that they knew is well-executed, and elevated by both Camille Coduri and Shaun Dingwall.

The episode is mostly a lot of running around until the Doctor and Rose can use the ridiculous Torchwood levers to activate the deus ex machina, and I'd rather not spend much time on it, because it doesn't really matter. It's awfully convenient that Jackie was able to just run away from the Cybermen before her conversion (shame Yvonne didn't think of that), and that Yvonne was able to overcome her own conversion (Danny Pink earned it, Yvonne - you did not), and that the Daleks and Cybermen were able to be sucked back through the vortex without levelling all of London, and that the Void - explicitly stated in the last episode to contain absolutely nothing of any kind - nonetheless gives off background radiation, but that's how these things go sometimes.

And then there's the ending, after Rose is lost. The Doctor with his head pressed against the wall is iconic for a reason, and David Tennant is masterful with his stiff-upper-lipness throughout. Billie Piper also does a very good job, but I don't empathize with her as much. I'm just not enough of a Doc/Rose shipper. Murray Gold does some of his best work with the bass-heavy music track that's used in this section of the episode. Apparently the track is called "Doomsday" on the soundtrack, which...sure, makes sense. It's prompted me to look up who the heck provided the vocals for the various themes in these two series, and the answer is Melanie Pappenheim, if you're as curious as I was.

And so endeth the life of Rose Tyler, may she rest in peace.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • I've never been really sure how I feel about Doctor and Rose together. Plot wise it doesn't make much sense, they are completely different species, and it's been pointed out previously to them multiple times how they couldn't ever grow old together. But Tennant and Piper have good chemistry, so I enjoy it for that.

    The Cult of Skaro, in its prime, is one of those concepts that merits its own episode. War-gaming as the enemy as a way to find tactics to beat them. Alas, even now I'm getting flashbacks/flashforwards to the dodgy prosthetic makeup to come.

  • source
  • parent