French is when people speak sloppy Latin uncorrected for 1500 years
post
I wonder when French took the wrong path, because it seems unexplainable to me how we end up from Latin's "aqua" to French's "eau"
One plausible etymology is:
aqua > agua > egua > ewa > ewe > eawe > eaw > eau > o
So first the k sound changed to a g, then the initial a became an e, which lengthened to a diphthong, the final sound disappeared, the new final sound turned from a consonant into a vowel (like an oo) and the resulting triphthong reduced to a monophthong.
The elision of medial g is pretty surprising to me though.
Are you sure that the Q is supposed to be read like a K? It does not seem to be the case in other neo-latin languages such as Italian and IIRC Spanish
Edit: i searched and it seems that the sound of Q could've been /kสท/ which makes sense
i am not a latin expertโ i barelly know it in fact, btw
Yes, Latin qu was pronounced /kสท/, which became straight /kw/ in English. I don't know which it was in Old French. Italian does have qu which is pronounced /kw/.
Italian does have qu which is pronounced /kw/
Same in German actually no
Sorry bud, but in German it usually (though not always ill grant you) is pronounced /kv/ :) quark, quasseln, usw
Oh dang you're right, read your comment too quickly and mixed up v and w, lol
What's the difference between /kสท/ and /kw/ though? Never seen that first notation
Italian does have qu which is pronounced /kw/.
I can confirm this as native speaker :3
here is a whole video on that exact topic
Aqua โก๏ธ eau is one of the explained examples ๐
I wonder when French took the wrong path,
When did Caesar invade Transalpine Gaul?
theres also un oeil ( 1 eye) vs les yeux (2 eyes) like wtf. or my favorite: poisson for fish. Fish is poisoned !
This is pretty much my experience attempting to learn french. I can't pronounce it worth a damn either.
Bout ready to toss it out, say fuck it, and switch to Italian.
God, I hate that retarded cat meme so much...
all 27 comments