If she hadn't become a vociferous anti civil rights activist the reality is a lot of us would still be tired of the books and frustrated with elements of them, but there'd be less anger when they come up. There were plenty of people getting real sick of how popular they'd remained in the mid 10s.

I read them all as a kid and loved them, but I was definitely tired of how much cultural space they took up for so fucking long. And the criticisms are valid, the books did an amazing job of inspiring obsession in a kid of the time, they felt like they grew with me, they had so much room to imagine in, and they were also full of holes, mid prose, and the sort of issues I'm kinda shocked my parents didn't feel the need to have a conversation about.

But also, would people be as vocal about these issues if it wasn't the largest media franchise under individual control and controlled by someone who has funded massive rollbacks in rights for a group she's bigoted towards? Obviously not, we'd just still be saying to read another book, not arguing not to continue purchasing products from the franchise.