you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 7 points 1 week ago (2 children)

The person I replied to, not you, took my critique of a meme and brought up revolution

Well yes, you seemed to be thinking that we're defending capitalism here or something. Often when people come in from out of instance with a reply that seems out of left field, there is some level of ignorance of left politics going on. So I made a best guess clarification based on what I figured the confusion might be. Your response has only lost me as to what your criticism even is. I'm not sure what pointing out flaws in small scale anarchist commune thinking has to do with siding with conservatives. The other poster looks like they tried to do what I did, with making a best guess, and you seem to be annoyed that they preached at you in the process.

If people are reading you wrong, you gotta tell em how. We aren't mind-readers and it's almost never personal, the corrections or preaching. If it feels patronizing sometimes, I'm sorry, but people come in hot with weird shit every so often and there's only so much one can do if the person provides little information/context for what they're saying.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] -3 points 1 week ago (1 child)

    This broken ping pong chain of people is aggravating. You are mostly fine other than your assumption essay, but good lord.

    The mind reading goes both ways. How am I to know that a misreading is a misreading and not bad faith? How did you connect rhyme/parallel to siding?

    If not for the fact that communists in much of the world don't have much political space below them, I'd say the meme is punching down. I can't see that and stereotyping as anything but either useless or aiding capitalists by creating toxicity in anticapitalist places. I cannot see the meme as anything but needlessly mean-spirited.

    Am I truly so incomprehensible? I cannot comprehend my initial reply containing so much information about myself to fuel two useful and well-thought, lengthy replies without baseless assumptions. Nor can I understand the effort put in or joy taken from writing so much when a question of less than ten words could have sufficed. So I can do nothing but assume the opposite.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 6 points 1 week ago

    Nor can I understand the effort put in or joy taken from writing so much when a question of less than ten words could have sufficed.

    Well in a forum context like this, it (usually) takes less effort to guess and write a response than to write a question then wait for the person to respond, potentially forget about the entire conversational context in the meantime, and then IF they clarify, go back to the context and see what it clarified in order to converse about it further.

    I do in fact write questions sometimes in spite of this, but it can be like pulling teeth sometimes getting a straightforward answer of people. You just never know.

    I cannot see the meme as anything but needlessly mean-spirited.

    That seems like a valid criticism to me. Though the way I take the meme, I think it is probably coming from a place of dealing with anarchists who talk down to marxist-leninists, and so from that standpoint, it's more of a response to them than it is an attempt to "put them in their place" or something. Especially in the western "left", there is a history of so-called anarchists who don't really accomplish much of anything yet are perfectly happy to shit on socialist projects that have accomplished incredible things for their people as "authoritarian" or whatever. So it's not a disagreement that started today, ya know.

  • source
  • parent