I hope they do this in the whole country, we're already getting bombarded enough with those commercials on TV. Don't need constant reminders about cheap airline tickets on the street...
post
Does this really set legal precedent for cities outside the Netherlands like the article suggests?
Yes. Not precedent as in American law where "they've done it this way in the past so we don't need to think about it again and just copy the previous ruling" but precedent as in other cities have now seen a) it can be done b) how to do it. This makes it easier to do it in their cities. It's also in a highly influential city when it comes to laws and courts.
legal precedent
This term has quite different meanings, depending where you are.
Why the hell do fossil fuel companies even need to advertise?
They don't offer anything unique, fuel is fuel. If it's for home heating or electricity I do t exactly have a choice in who provides It.
If it's gas for a vehicle I'm choosing whoever is closest when I need gas because everyone is always magocally the exact same price everywhere.
How does advertising even benefit them at all?
Propaganda is a powerful manipulator. Design/ad budgets change how people think about things. Fossil fuel companies should absolutely not be allowed to spend money on ads: that money should go toward climate reparations.
Greenwashing.
I am Dutch and all Shell adds I have seen is about how much they are moving into green technology.
Yet, during a share holders meeting they proudly state they will not do that and invest more in oil because 'the oil market still saw growth.'
Or that the green investments is mostly into hydrogen, so that they can continue with their production scarcity nonsense.
fossil fuels, fossil-powered transport, and the aviation sector in all public spaces
I think this includes ads for non-electric cars, which is huge. Flights too.
Ban car and meat ads too.
Does this extend to ads for public transport?
Dutch Railways have fully run on green energy since 2017. AFAIK there are no other train companies running on diesel anymore either. Buses are getting electrified, albeit slowly.
Yes there are trains running on diesel in the Netherlands. Especially in the border areas
But NS (= Dutch Railways) doesn't right?
Edit: I misinterpreted your comment.
No, NS doesn't run diesel trains anymore.
It's not my comment but I figured. I wonder though about the original question; where do they draw the line. So no ads for airplanes and gas stations, obvious, but how about some plastic lunch box or a bus company? What about train tickets where a part of the trip is with a diesel train. Surely the city will not allow something that is questionable at some point.
Adverts for public transport? Makes about as much sense as adverts for fossil fuel - I guess. I don't recall ever seing one where I live though.
all 20 comments