Depends entirely on how you interpret the question. It could be read as "What's a recent game you've tried..." (as in, a recently released game that you tried), as you've done, or "What's a recent game you've tried..." (as in, a game you've tried recently) as the person you're responding to did.

I think either interpretation is fine since the title doesn't actually clarify either way.

I started gaming in the 80's my first game was doom on a 286. Skyrim release date was recent for me and I only recently played skyrim for the first time.

The question is "What's a recent game you've tried playing..?"

Not 'What's a recently released game you've tried playing..?'

It is when you're over 40.