you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 36 points 2 months ago (10 children)

What people are gonna miss is this was the intended outcome:

The song offers a step-by-step guide on how to organize local, leaderless structures aimed at countering far-right movements. It advocates strict operational security, such as avoiding digital footprints and relying on face-to-face communication. It also describes tactics for investigating political opponents and publicizing their identities and affiliations, a practice often referred to as "outing" or doxing.

The lyrics also include references to militant action and express solidarity with individuals who have been found guilty of leading violent attacks on neo-Nazis.

ZDF director Norbert Himmler said he stood by the decision to cancel the performance: "In my view, the lyrics unquestionably provide instructions for a leftist resistance willing to use violence," he told the German daily Süddeutsche Zeitung.

They absolutely shouldn't have allowed the song to be aired, that's why the creators wanted to air the song, and submitted the lyrics months ahead.

Either the plug gets pulled early or late minute, someone was going to pull the plug once the people in power realized what was going thru common procedure. Doing it this way highlights both how ineffective procedural opppsition is, but also how to twist it to their advantage.

At the same time, he admitted that his station should have handled the case differently: "We can be faulted for the last-minute cancellation," he said, adding, "We should have asked ourselves basic questions earlier — ideally before inviting the artists."

Eight members of the ZDF Television Council have criticized the broadcaster over the cancellation. In an open letter published on Monday by the online outlet netzpolitik.org, the council members argued that ZDF missed an opportunity to spark a debate about right-wing extremism in Germany and the various ways to combat it.

They not only got their discussion raised, they gave the agency that should be keeping an eye on this shit a giant black eye that they're not doing their jobs properly.

  • source
  • hideshow 10 child comments
  • [–] 39 points 2 months ago* (4 children)

    unquestionably provide instructions for a leftist resistance willing to use violence

    Exactly its resistance. Violent resistance to fascism is morally correct. Dude basically admitted that resisting fascism is against his ideals.

    Also it definitely should have been aired. There are lots of songs out there describing much worse things that get aired without issue. Art is not legal advice and lyrics dont have to only contain things that are legal. And they werent planning to air it without comment, but with loads of context and discussion.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [+] -18 points 2 months ago (2 children)

    That is not what's happening....

    Like, before you think the lyrics should be allowed for broadcast, go and look at them.

    The lyrics were intentionally written to violate laws and everyone knew they would eventually be told not to play it. There was no scenario this song aired on TV.

    It'd be like playing an American classic like "make crack like this" except "how to make and plant bombs".

    To highlight that if someone makes the type of "song" but for the right, it most likely wouldn't get caught in time thru normal means to stop it from being broadcast.

    Which is a very pertinent issue today in Germany with all the far right shit.

    The system cant play whack amole thru the gish gallop, it's trying and it's fucking failing.

    So this shoves it in everyone's face in a weird way that everyone regardless of stance says:

    Maybe violent rhetoric is out of hand...

    It reminds the right they're not the only ones who can act violent.

    It gives the far right the same vibes as seeing Malcom X and 500 Black Panthers with AR15s march past Ronald Reagan.

    But in a way that not a single law or even regulation was actually violated.

    That's German humor. Making somebody look like an idiot but also be forced to agree with you on the larger point.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 23 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago)

    The lyrics were intentionally written to violate laws and everyone knew they would eventually be told not to play it.

    There is nothing in that song that actually is illegal. Even the ZDF (broadcaster who denied the song being aired) never claimed so. They just said a vague "its a call for violence", which it might be, but artistic freedom allows for such things in Germany, as has the artists previously shown when he performed his other grey area song on... you guessed it ... the ZDF

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 12 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago)

    before you think the lyrics should be allowed for broadcast, go and look at them

    Motherfucker ive been banging this song on full volume on my speakers since it came out. I know whats in there and i know that its good advice for how to deal with nazis in your neighbourhood. Track them, record them, get into their circles, archive everything, contact their employers and landlords. Make it so they dont feel safe openly being nazis. Make sure you can defend yourself if you get caught.

    But i also know that putting all that into a song is perfectly legal.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 13 points 2 months ago

    They absolutely shouldn’t have allowed the song to be aired

    Why?

    They constantly air things where violence is a key part of the content, they show movies & shows where people do questionable things, air comedians that joke about rape and in general have a wide variety of content. How come an artistic piece such a song, being featured in an satire program, is somehow not allowable when those other things are?

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 8 points 2 months ago

    ZDF director Norbert Himmler said he stood by the decision to cancel the performance: “In my view, the lyrics unquestionably provide instructions for a leftist resistance willing to use violence,”

    One might argue, that he did the perfect thing at the perfect time to maximize the impact of this song, I'd wager even maximizing it more than a simple airing at something past ten in the night would have done. That man is not stupid and he knows how media works, that's why he's where he is. He saved face, he took the ZDF out of the legal and conservative line of fire and looking at the result, well, chapeau, almost.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 7 points 2 months ago (1 child)

    I don't know where you're getting this from. It's certainly not true that this was intended, ZDF pulled the plug extremely late, or rather, one single person did after it was already explicitly greenlit (which has some serious implications for corruption too)

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 2 points 2 months ago

    Framed differently: If he wanted to Streisand it, he nailed it.

    The other comment alleges that this may have been intentional: Feign incompetence for plausible deniability while precisely timing the pull for maximum effect.

  • source
  • parent